“Well I’d rather see you dead, little girl
Than to be with another man
Catch you with another man
That’s the end’a little girl”
John Lennon and Paul McCartney
“I don’t know why you girls aren’t attracted to me but I will punish you all for it. …….. If I can’t have you girls, I will destroy you. [laughs] You denied me a happy life and in turn I will deny all of you life, it’s only fair. I hate all of you.”
Male entitlement is a deadly seam running through male violence against women whether coercive control, FGM, rape, prostitution, trafficking or murder.
According to government statistics, approximately 85,000 women are raped on average in England and Wales every year, that’s an average of 233 women raped by men in the UK every day. Last year in the UK, 142 women were killed through suspected male violence, that’s one dead woman every 2.5 days; and between January and April this year, 50 UK women have been killed. The World Health Organisation estimates that between 100 and 140 million girls and women worldwide have been subjected to one of the first three types of female genital mutilation. Prostitution, pornography and trafficking reduce women to commodities, possessions and objects for market exchange, men the purchasers, controllers and profit-makers. It is estimated that prostitution revenue is around £110 billion per year worldwide, involves around 40-42 million people worldwide, of which 90% are dependent on a procurer, 75% are between 13 and 25 years old and the overwhelming majority are women. The global pornography industry was estimated to be worth £57 billion in 2006. Approximately 230 girls are still missing, more than a month after they were abducted in Chibok, Nigeria. Women are still routinely ‘given away’ by their fathers in marriage ceremonies and fathers, not mothers are named on marriage certificates. Male entitlement to women and girls and male violence against women and girls are inextricable.
Mass killings make news headlines in the way day-to-day fatal violence rarely does. The day after Elliott Rodger murdered six people, 82-year old Harold Ambrose called the police from the home he shared with his wife in Boxted, Essex, and told them that he had shot her dead. When armed police reached the house, they found 77-year-old Wendy Ambrose, sitting dead in a chair in the living room with two gunshots to her head and face. Harold Ambrose was found dead in the garden with a single gunshot wound to his head. Harold Ambrose’s name has not trended on twitter, it has not made widespread national, let alone international, news coverage. A man killing a woman is so ‘everyday’ that those who set the agenda do not deem it worthy of attention.
Male entitlement to women’s spaces crosses the realms of the theoretical, cultural and physical. Whether it’s Seven Brides for Seven Brothers aka Stockholm Syndrome: the musical, misogynist fantasies of emotional and sexual abuse in the guise of stories for children or adult women, Tom Jones (for example and by no alone) with his songs of Christmas rape or murdering women, popular culture from fairy-tale to pop-music and film is littered with the message that women exist for men. The guy gets the girl. Reward. Happy ending. Some of the men that haven’t management to grasp the intricacies of women’s liberation from structural oppression demand to be, rather than support, feminists. Socially constructed gender and biological sex become conflated, woman is seen as a state of mind. Women-only conferences are threatened by men’s rights activists and women’s domestic and sexual violence services are increasingly re-commissioned as ‘gender-neutral’ services under a barely disguised reactionary ideology. And whilst I was delighted to learn that Sweden has just elected the only formal feminist party to the EU parliament with a Roma woman, Soraya Post as its representative, my heart sank when I read that the role of men is seen as the same as that of women in the Swedish Feminist Initiative. How can we be the same when in patriarchal society we are anything but?
It has now been confirmed that Elliot Rodgers killed six people, four men and two women, the motivating force of his entitled misogyny and bitter jealously revealed in his self-recorded “last video”. Elliot Rodger’s sense of entitlement is glaringly obvious. Prostitution was even suggested as a possible – missed – solution to Rodger’s choice to kill. As explored here by Megan Murphy “What could possibly be a better cure for male entitlement than more male entitlement?” Glaringly obvious and not unusual, male entitlement is frequently accepted as an excuse or justification for everyday fatal male violence against women. For most women, leaving a violent relationship is the best way to end the violence (63%) but for over a third it is not: the violence reduced for eight per cent, stayed about the same for five per cent,changed to something else, such as stalking and other harassment, for 18 per cent, got worse for three per cent and only started when they split up for three per cent. In my tracking of UK women killed through male violence, women being killed by men when they ended relationships, as they left, as they formed relationships with others or after leaving a violence relationship is ever present: Jabeen Younis, 30; Samantha Medland, 24; Rosemary Gill, 48; Chloe Siokos, 80; Gabielle Stanley, 28; Julie Beattie, 24; Da In Lee, 22; Shaista Khatoon, 33; Marion Vita, 48; Janee Parsons, 31. This list could go on and on. Whilst men’s murderous entitlement to women’s spaces, bodies and lives continues unchecked and sometimes supported by liberal capitalist ideology, male violence against women and girls will continue and the lists of women killed by men will continue to grow longer.
i wish someone would have the guts to discuss the trans agenda.. my experience was of my body, love and trust being used, abused betrayed and commodified by a man who then claimed he was actually a woman and truly believes that make up, clothes and genital mutilation is all there is to womanhood.. biology, experience.. those count for nothing, far from solidarity, the whole trans community is filled with a hatred of real women. .. yet when he left me suicidal and broken and started wearing a wig, the whole world was cheering him on.. whenever i try to explain what he did to me, and how ludicrous the whole charade is, im accused of being bitter and twisting the truth..especially by other women.
This is the best piece I have read on the Rodger murders, and the only one to explicitly connect his actions to culturally accepted misogynist structures and ordinary, widely held male attitudes towards women, which usually find their expression in private acts of exploitation and violence against one woman rather than mass public killings. The cultural breadth and very ordinariness of misogyny is what we need to take away from this incident, rather than characterise it as ‘misogynist extremism’ (per Laurie Penny).
I’m also glad you discussed the sex industry as a fundamental pillar of male entitlement and dehumanisation of women. I’ve had it up to here with liberal feminists like Penny defending the mass commodification of women and girls as objects for male sexual use as compatible with women’s liberation. Any feminism that refuses to analyse male domination as a whole system and cordons off parts of it from critique is a useless feminism.
Thank you. I know – the failure to see the connection between the commodification of women and structural oppression of all women infuriates/baffles/saddens me.
Pingback: If I can’t have you, I will destroy you | OUT of My Panties, Now!!!